Dear President
Melancon and President Costello,
Recent world events
have increased the importance, and potential benefits, of
administering the CPA examination in other countries. Thus, I
respectfully reiterate my request that NASBA and the AICPA take
immediate action to begin administering the U.S. CPA examination
outside the U.S. This is an idea whose time has come, which will
benefit the U.S. accounting profession, NASBA, the AICPA, American
companies doing business overseas, and thousands of international
CPA candidates each year. In addition, administering the CPA exam
in other countries will aid the efforts of homeland security by the
U.S. Immigration Service and the U.S. Customs Office.
It has been a little
over two years since my previous letter. In a separate mailing I
will forward a copy of my letter dated March 6, 2002 and the related
article in the December 2001 CPA Journal so I won’t repeat
the reasons for action described in those documents. Shown below
are recent developments that further exacerbate the need for action.
Developments
Events around the world since March of
2002 call out to NASBA and the AICPA to take action, including:
|
1. |
China: China is changing its view on accounting standards. Unfortunately, China is beginning to focus on International
Accounting Standards rather than U.S. accounting standards. That
has been the risk from the beginning, that while most countries have
looked to U.S. accounting as the gold standard, with the consequent
taking of the U.S. CPA examination by candidates from around the
world, this can change in a heartbeat. International candidates
are experiencing greater costs and difficulties to take the U.S. CPA
examination. China is particularly important because: |
| |
 |
China has 20% of the world’s population. |
| |
 |
China is the world’s fastest growing economy. |
| |
 |
Chinese visa applicants face an insurmountable hurdle trying
to get a visa to the U.S. |
 |
|
2. |
Homeland
Security: Homeland security
efforts will benefit from administering the CPA examination to
international candidates in other countries, rather than annually
having 7,000 – 10,000 people travel to the U.S. to take the CPA
examination. Probably none of the people entering the U.S. to take
the CPA examination are any type of security threat. However, the
man-hours spent handling their visa applications, as well as
clearing them through Immigration and Customs upon entering the
U.S., could be spent more effectively on pressing matters of
national security. |
 |
|
3. |
Increased Visa
Restrictions: Homeland security actions have made it much
more difficult, if not impossible, for citizens of many countries
around the world to obtain a USA visa. As a result, some
candidates, who in the past would have experienced few problems with
a visa, now are unable to obtain a visa. |
 |
|
4. |
Declining
Numbers of Candidates: The number of CPA candidates has been
declining and has dropped considerably at the onset of computerized
testing. Administering the CPA exam in other countries to would
dramatically increase the number of international candidates. For
example, President Kotaro Anjo of ANJO International in Japan
estimates that the number of Japanese candidates would more than
double if the CPA exam were administered in Japan.
|
 |
|
5. |
Cost to
Candidates: Declining numbers can only increase the
cost-per-candidate to administer the CPA exam. In contrast,
administering the CPA exam outside the U.S. will increase the total
number of candidates and correspondingly decrease the
cost-per-candidate. Monies no longer paid to airlines and hotels
will benefit NASBA, the State Boards of Accountancy, and U.S.
candidates.
For example, assume that
administering the CPA exam outside the U.S. quadruples the number of
international candidates to 40,000 individuals and that travel costs
average $2,000 per person. Annual travel costs of $80,000,000
(40,000 x $2,000) will be avoided by administering the CPA exam
outside the U.S. Paying an additional fee of $1,000 for the right
to sit for the CPA exam in one’s own country will still leave an
international candidate $1,000 ahead (plus time and money saved by
reduced travel time). International candidates not convinced of
the cost-benefit of paying the additional $1,000 administrative fee
will be free to travel to the U.S.
NASBA and
the State Boards of Accountancy could annually have $40,000,000
of additional fees (40,000 x $1,000) to cover costs for
administering the CPA exam outside the U.S., balancing their
budgets, and reducing the cost-per-candidate to U.S. candidates.
|
 |
|
6. |
Computer-Based Testing: The successful launching of the
computer-based CPA exam in April 2004 has been great for the
accounting profession. However, the fact that Prometric has
testing centers worldwide calls out for utilizing some of those
sites outside the USA to make life easier for international
candidates. Imagine the frustration an international candidate
feels when passing a Prometric testing center in his hometown on the
way to the airport to travel to another country to sit down at a
computer at a similar Prometric site in the USA to take the CPA
exam. |
Also, the change to CBT
has created an unintentional bias against international
candidates. The extraordinary cost of traveling to the USA to
take the CPA exam makes it much more difficult to sit just for one
section of the CPA exam, so international candidates are more
pressed to prepare for multiple sections at a time.
Open Letter
to the AICPA and NASBA Website
|
I have continued receiving messages
from interested people and organizations throughout the world,
although I have done nothing to encourage people to visit my website
and add their names to the “Open Letter to the AICPA and NASBA”. The number of countries has doubled, from 17 to 35, since
2002. Most people have written comments and/or suggestions. You
are welcome to review their comments if you wish. Here is a
synopsis of the people who have requested that their names be added
to the “Open Letter”: |
 |
 |
233 individuals and organizations |
 |
From 35 different countries, including every continent except
Antarctica: |
Australia
China
Germany
Japan
Nairobi
Pakistan
South Korea
Turkey
USA |
Bolivia
Dubai
Greece
Jordan
Netherlands
Palestine
South Africa
Uganda
West Indies |
Brazil
Egypt
Hong Kong
Kuwait
New Zealand
Saudi Arabia
Taiwan
United Arab Emirate
Yemen |
Canada
France
India
Lebanon
Oman
Senegal
Trinidad
United Kingdom |
I respectfully
request that you consider the information in this letter, along with
your sense of fairness to international candidates, and your concern
for the American accounting profession, to take immediate action to
begin administering the CPA examination in other countries.
|